pg.lost It's Not Me, It's You!
  Full ReviewUser Ratings (49)
Tracklist:
1. The Day Shift
2. Head High
3. Pascal's Law
4. Maquina
5. Jonathan
6. Siren
Bonus Tracks
7. Yes I Am
8. Kardusen

Ranking: #33 for 2008

You Say:
3.9
excellent


User Rating Distribution:
Chart.
On 7 Lists

Members Also Liked:

Godspeed You! Black Emperor - Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To
Godspeed You! Black Emperor - F# A# ∞
dredg - El Cielo
Explosions in the Sky - The Earth is Not a Cold Dead Place
Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago
Sigur Ros - ( )
Brand New - The Devil And God Are Raging Inside Me
4.5
superb
John A. Hanson STAFF (140 Reviews)

2008-07-01 | 113 comments | 5,182 views

What pg.lost have crafted with their new record, It’s Not Me, It’s You!”, is a post-rock album that should attract the attention of all the Explosions in the Sky whoring, A Silver Mt Zion loving, Yndi Halda worshipping post-rock kids ad get them to divert their attention away from Sigur Ros’ latest “breathtaking” record of the year candidate. While the transition from their first EP to their first full length has seen pg.lost grow a little more in line with traditional post-rock bands, they still like to defy what you expect them to do, and then do so in an absolutely deft manner.

The record begins innocuously with “The Day Shift”, which begins and ebbs like a normal post rock song would, the intro building towards its eventual “climax”, featuring one of the key pegs in the pg.lost cog: the distortion in a pg.lost song is done so wonderfully, you’ll begin to wonder if it really counts as distortion or if the music is just so beautiful you can’t hear it straight. As it begins to wind down, and you hear what would expectedly be the last few guitar notes being plucked, the song explodes into something AT LEAST five times louder and more epic than it was before. The dual guitars interweaving as the drums crash around, while the song ends in a heavily distorted solo.

Its hard to describe something so ***ing brilliant, people.

The middle of the album proceeds more tamely, with “Head High” being the only slightly weak point of the album, a generic, but still solid, track accompanied by cliché after cliché. Luckily Every song following lives up to the quality height of “The Day Shift”. While “Pascal’s Law” showcases that they can write a traditional post-rock songs and add various flairs to it (the 5 minutes of high tempo snare hits are delicious), as they abuse their echo pedals in its climax. “Maquina” continues on a similar path, except focuses more on its final crescendo than any sort of neat trickery.

What makes pg.lost different/so enthralling is that they couldn’t care less about making any part of their music “pretty”. Even in moments that should be glossy and stylized, such as the beginning of “Jonathan” where the extremely “dirty” (aka “we can mess with the levels on this part of the mix a lot!”) guitar riff makes the otherwise lush guitar work grounded, and at the same time making a fantastic juxtaposition between the ugliness of pg.lost’s work with the inherent beauty. The final song “Siren” is arguably the best song recorded this year, especially when taken in context of the album.

The most minimalist song in composition, “Siren” begins with little else other than a repeating guitar line and light synths. It goes on like this for nearly five minutes, every few moments taking the time to draw you back in with a individual guitar lick or shift in the song itself, until the drums kick in and the only true vocals on the album are heard. The song steadily builds throughout its duration, picking up steam and additional instruments until it finally erupts in a cacophony of guitars, drum crashes, and a piercing yell in the background. It is the perfect ending to the record, a release of energy that seems to have more in common with the likes of Envy than, lets say, Eluvium.

It’s Not Me, It’s You! is not for everyone, and it isn’t even for every post-rock fan. It’s a long, trying album seemingly designed to test your patience in short bursts, implanting you with the knowledge that yes, in time everything will make sense in any given song. Even when pg.lost turn into a “standard” post-rock band, they do it well and above most of their peers, and when pg.lost are *pg.lost*, they can challenge anyone else in the game when it comes to sheer talent and virtuosity. While the album may ride a little too heavily on the guitarists for many peoples tastes, it’s the best post-rock album I’ve heard since Yndi Halda’s Enjoy Eternal Bliss, and I surely hope pg.lost can build upon this and craft an album great enough to land them in direct comparisons with the Sigur Ros’ and GY!BE’s of the world.

Email this Review to a Friend

Recent reviews by this author
Cynic Traced In Air
Mesa Verde The Old Road
Rise Against Appeal To Reason
Portugal. The Man Censored Colors
Jardin de la Croix Pomeroy
Past Lives Strange Symmetry

Page 1 of 6 | Next > | >>
Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 9730
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4.5

It's like a 4.2 review but its my personal favorite release of the year so I bumped up the rating.

Digging: Mesa Verde - The Old Road

iarescientists


Comments: 3432
07.02.08

Album Rating: 2.5

first sentence is sure to cause a stir among numerous sputnik fags

Digging: Verse En Coma - Rialto

NortherlyNanook


Comments: 806
07.02.08


go back to being in other people's summaries



I wanna find this

Digging: Majority Rule - Emergency Numbers

JumpTheF**kUp


Comments: 1988
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4.5

review is good 10/10

Digging: Brand New - The Devil And God Are Raging Inside Me

The Jungler
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 4819
07.02.08


**** you.

I guess I'll listen to this.

ninjuice


Comments: 1901
07.02.08


Quote:
Luckily Every song following lives up to the quality height


Small error, great review otherwise.

Loud post-rock? Apparently I need to hear this.

Digging: The Mars Volta - De-Loused in the Comatorium

astrel


Comments: 1714
07.02.08


I have heard stuff from their EP, and it was pretty pimp.

Digging: dredg - El Cielo

mynameischan
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 9607
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4

LOUD POST ROCK? APPARENLTY I NEED TO HEAR THIS

Digging: Counting Crows - August And Everything After

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 9730
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4.5

APPARENTLY

ninjuice


Comments: 1901
07.02.08


Haha...

mynameischan
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 9607
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4

i just flew to japan and picked this up

kalanamak


Comments: 5
07.02.08


i have to get this!!!

foreverendeared


Comments: 2624
07.02.08


typo in first sentence. "ad" instead of "and"

great review though. first thing i thought of was pg.99. after the first paragraph i thought i need to get this

Digging: Esperanza Spalding - Esperanza

rasputin
Contributing Reviewer


Comments: 4959
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4

Looking forward to listening to this

Digging: Grief - Come to Grief

Minus The Flair


Comments: 200
07.02.08


EP was solid, Yes I Am is an awesome song. Will definitely pick this one up.

Digging: Fight Like Apes - ...And The Mystery Of The Golden Medallion

HighandDriving


Comments: 1965
07.02.08


Good review, I thought of pg. 99 also.

Digging: Anthony Green - Avalon

FlawedPerfection
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 2519
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4

Most of this album is so ridiculously good.



Unfortunately tracks 2 and 3 and to some extent 4 are kinda weak.

Digging: The Tallest Man on Earth - Shallow Graves

MassiveAttack


Comments: 124
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4

yea i liked their ep 3-3.5 for me so I'm interested for their debut

Digging: John Murphy - Sunshine (Soundtrack)

mynameischan
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 9607
07.02.08

Album Rating: 4

ugh this isgood

iarescientists


Comments: 3432
07.02.08

Album Rating: 2.5

don't fall into the trap chan!

Page 1 of 6 | Next > | >>


You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ / site forum / staff / contact us
Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Site Copyright 2005-2008 Sputnikmusic.com  All Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors